Alarplasty Repair Guide

Repairing an over-done alarplasty

An alarplasty cuts skin from the nostrils to make them smaller. That skin doesn't grow back. This guide explains, in plain words, the main repair options, what each one can and can't do, and what the research says.

Based on published studies, surgeons' public case photos and experiences patients have shared. Not medical advice.

A nose seen from below A nose from underneath, showing the tip, the columella between the nostrils, the nostril wings, and the two places an alarplasty usually cuts: the wedge on the outside of the wing and the sill at the bottom of the nostril. the tip wing (ala) columella crease wedge cut sill cut
Looking up at a nose. The red dashed areas are where an alarplasty usually cuts. Some surgeons cut one, some cut both.

The options at a glance

Four kinds of repair came up again and again. Click a name to jump to it.

#MethodWhat it can doScar riskHow provenVerdict
1DerotationHides uneven nostrils if your tip was turned up. Adds no tissue.LowThinHelper, not a fix
2Composite grafts (ear skin + cartilage)Two very different ways to place them:
2aInternalAdds a little size and flare from inside the nostril.MediumGoodThe middle ground
2bExternalRebuilds the cut wedge or sill directly.HighStrongWorks, but shows
3FlapsSkin moved while still attached to its blood supply:
3aAlar lobule flapFixes notches and teardrop shapes. Doesn't add size.LowOne small studyGentlest option
3bLip or cheek island flapBrings in new living skin, so in theory the most size.HighVery thinPromising, unproven
4Other optionsV-to-Y advancement, fixing weak cartilage, scar release and scar care.VariesVariesSupporting fixes

"Verdict" is a plain-language summary of the evidence below, not a doctor's rating.

Not sure where to start? Answer three questions Nothing is saved
Where were you cut?
Is your nose tip turned up more than it used to be?
What bothers you most?

Pick your answers to see which sections to read first.

Before you start

What did the alarplasty take?

The right repair depends on what's missing. Two different cuts cause two different problems.

Sill cut

Skin taken from the floor of each nostril.

Nostrils get smaller. Notches or "teardrop" shapes can form.

Wedge cut

A slice taken from the outside of each wing.

Wings get pulled in. You lose flare.

Both (a "Weir")

Sill and wedge together. A common approach.

Smaller nostrils, notches and lost flare.

Each method below helps with some of these and not others:

  • Shape: a round nostril instead of a notch, a teardrop or a flat, pinched wing.
  • Size: a bigger opening. This needs new tissue, because the old tissue is gone.
  • Flare: wings that curve outward. The wedge cut is what usually takes this.
More on this Notch types, reports, an example

Not every notch is the same notch

  1. Weak cartilage. The wing caves in because its support was trimmed. Usually fixable with cartilage grafts.
  2. A rim that's pulled up (retraction). Often fixable with grafts placed inside the nose.
  3. Skin cut away by alarplasty. The shortage is on the outside, and there's no easy fix. This is the most common case after alarplasty.

Find out what was actually done

Operative reports sometimes leave out or understate the alarplasty. In one case, revision surgeons measured about 5 mm taken from each side, where the original surgeon claimed 2 mm. Get an independent surgeon to examine you and write down the measurements first.

Not every alarplasty is aggressive

Dr. Tolga Bilece, November 2025: A conservative alarplasty: only a thin sliver of outer skin removed, nostril size kept. On the operating table.

Dr. Tolga Bilece, November 2025

A conservative alarplasty: only a thin sliver of outer skin removed, nostril size kept. On the operating table.

View on Instagram

1

Derotation

A helper, not a fixOnly if your tip was turned upKeeps your current tissue

Tip the point of the nose down a little, so less of the inside of the nostrils shows.

Side view of a nose. The slider turns the tip up or down, and more of the nostril shows when it turns up. nose tip angle ≈ 110°

Nostril show: a lot. This is an over-rotated, "upturned" tip.

The nostril never gets bigger. Derotation changes what people see. It doesn't put skin back.

Can help if

  • Your tip got turned up in surgery
  • Your alarplasty was mild to moderate
  • Your nostrils look better when you push the tip down

Won't help if

  • A lot of skin was cut
  • Your tip wasn't turned up
  • Your wing was stitched too low compared to the columella

Trade-offs

  • Usually needs a strong support graft (an SEG, often rib), which can feel stiff
  • Overdone, it can look older or droopy
  • It's another full nose surgery

Key examples

Dr. Sam Most, June 2023: A long-term revision result. The nostrils look fuller after derotation. This patient never had an alarplasty. Video, so play it on Instagram.

Dr. Sam Most, June 2023

A long-term revision result. The nostrils look fuller after derotation. This patient never had an alarplasty. Video, so play it on Instagram.

View on Instagram

Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2025: Seven months after a revision to bring down an upturned tip.

Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2025

Seven months after a revision to bring down an upturned tip.

View on Instagram

Bottom line. Only worth it if your tip was turned up. It makes what you have left look its best, often in the same surgery as other repairs. It won't bring back what was cut.

More detail Why it might work, patient experiences, sources

Why it might help

Alarplasty damage is easiest to see when a lot of the nostril shows. Many patients also have their tips turned up in the same surgery, which puts the notches and uneven sides on display. Surgeons do treat nostril show as a real, fixable problem and even classify how the rims sit (Rohrich and Afrooz, 2019). But nobody has published derotation as an alarplasty repair. The idea comes from patients comparing hundreds of before and after photos.

The mirror test

In a mirror, gently push your nose tip down using your upper lip and cheek muscles. If the wings flare out more, rotation is probably part of your problem. If nothing changes, you're most likely missing skin. It's a rough clue, not a diagnosis.

What patients report

  • If there is more rotation, there is more nostril show. So you see the alarplasty deformity more easily.A patient who researched derotation
  • Nostril flare can be currently improved with downrotation. Flaps and skin grafts do not help for flare.A patient with eight surgeries, who was against derotation at first
  • With severe alar issues, simple derotation will not fix the issue.The same patient, months earlier, about her own case. Derotation pulled her nostrils further up, not out.

One patient's nostrils looked wider after his revision even though their size didn't change: his surgeon made the tip stick out less and propped up the collapsed wings. Later, a surgeon told the same patient his real issue was how the rim had been stitched, not rotation, and a US surgeon turned him down, saying his skin might not allow the derotation he wanted. Get examined before betting on this.

US surgeons named most often for strong derotation: Dr. Sam Most and Dr. Ari Hyman. Dr. Scott Owen and Dr. Steitz also came up.

A hand drawn sketch: from the side, the tip angle goes from about 106 degrees to 90; from the front, the nostrils go from pinched to wider
A patient's sketch of what derotation might change: tip angle from about 106° to 90°, nostrils wider instead of pinched.

More examples

Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2023: Three months after a revision to correct uneven nostrils. Shared as an example of strong derotation.

Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2023

Three months after a revision to correct uneven nostrils. Shared as an example of strong derotation.

View on Instagram

Sources

  • Rohrich RJ, Afrooz PN. Revisiting the Alar-Columellar Relationship: Classification and Correction. Plast Reconstr Surg 2019;144(2):340–346. PubMed
2

Composite grafts

Skin + cartilage from the earThe most studied option

Take a small piece of your ear that has two layers, skin and the cartilage under it, and stitch it into the nose to replace what was cut.

Composite graft vs. cartilage graft

"Ear graft" can mean two different things. A cartilage graft is cartilage only: it can prop up or reshape a wing, but it adds no skin, so it can't undo an alarplasty on its own. A composite graft is skin plus cartilage (sometimes skin and fat). It's the only kind of graft that puts skin back. This section is about composite grafts.

A small piece of skin and cartilage taken from the ear, made of three layers: skin, cartilage, skin. from the ear skincartilageskin a compositegraft Nose from below showing where the composite graft goes
Internal: the graft is tucked into the lining inside the nostril and pushes the wing outward (arrows). Hidden from the front, but the gain is modest.
2a. Internal2b. External
Where it goesInside the nostril. The wing is freed and the graft is tucked into the lining.On the outside of the wing, filling the wedge or sill that was cut.
What it can doModest extra size and a little flare.The most direct way to rebuild the shape that was cut.
Scar you'd seeOnly if someone looks up your nose.On the outside, around the patch.
Main riskShrinking back over time.Color mismatch, shrinking, not taking.
Can it be undone?Easier to remove.Hard. Removing it means more scars.
2a

Internal composite grafts

The middle ground

The wing is released from the inside, scar tissue is freed, and the composite graft is slipped into the nostril lining so the wing can sit further out. It doesn't rebuild the outside of the wedge, but it adds some size and flare without an outside scar. Many patients see it as the best balance.

Surgeons reported as doing it internally: Dr. Oguzhan Oguz, Dr. Shahriar Nazari (Iran), Dr. Blas García (Spain), Dr. Kidakorn Kiranantawat (Thailand), Dr. Ahmet Halit Aydın, and reportedly Dr. Khosh (US). Dr. Göde says he now only does them internally.

Diagram: a crescent marked on the ear, the spot on the nostril rim, and the graft fitted into the rim from inside the nostril
How an internal composite graft goes in: (A) marked on the ear, (B) the spot on the nostril rim, (C) fitted in from inside the nostril. Front Med 2026, Fig. 1. CC BY 4.0.

Key examples

Dr. Oguzhan Oguz: Rebuilding a lost nostril from the inside: before, at 1 month and at 7 months. It appears to have healed well. He posted the same case again in April 2026 as a video.
Internal

Dr. Oguzhan Oguz

Rebuilding a lost nostril from the inside: before, at 1 month and at 7 months. It appears to have healed well. He posted the same case again in April 2026 as a video.

Photo post · April 2026 video

Dr. Kidakorn Kiranantawat (Thailand), 2024: Severe nostril narrowing after cosmetic surgery, fixed with a composite graft from the ear. Shown 1 year and 10 months later.
Internal

Dr. Kidakorn Kiranantawat (Thailand), 2024

Severe nostril narrowing after cosmetic surgery, fixed with a composite graft from the ear. Shown 1 year and 10 months later.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde: "Larger and better nostrils are possible." Rib cartilage plus composite grafts, on darker skin.
Internal

Dr. Sercan Göde

"Larger and better nostrils are possible." Rib cartilage plus composite grafts, on darker skin.

View on Instagram

More internal examples 3 more
Dr. Ahmet Halit Aydın, May 2024: A complicated ethnic revision with a composite graft on one side. One of very few published examples on a Black patient.
Internal

Dr. Ahmet Halit Aydın, May 2024

A complicated ethnic revision with a composite graft on one side. One of very few published examples on a Black patient.

View on Instagram

Dr. Shahriar Nazari (Iran): From his Instagram stories, tagged "alar expansion". His captions read "nasal reconstruction and enlarging the nasal ala".
Internal

Dr. Shahriar Nazari (Iran)

From his Instagram stories, tagged "alar expansion". His captions read "nasal reconstruction and enlarging the nasal ala".

His Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, 2024: An alar retraction repair. One patient recalls this case differently, as outside grafts that scarred, so ask him directly.
Internal

Dr. Sercan Göde, 2024

An alar retraction repair. One patient recalls this case differently, as outside grafts that scarred, so ask him directly.

View on Instagram

2b

External composite grafts

Works, but shows

The composite graft is sewn into the outside of the wing, right where the wedge or sill was cut. It's the most direct way to rebuild the original shape, and it has decades of studies behind it. The catch is the outside scar, and ear skin doesn't always match nose skin, especially on darker skin.

Surgeons reported as doing it externally: Dr. Jason Roostaeian (US), Dr. Amir Sazgar (Iran), Dr. Shingyochi (Japan), Dr. Erkan Soylu, Dr. Fatullayev, and Dr. Ali Manafi (in his published study).

Photos from Manafi 2013: a wedge of skin taken where the earlobe meets the rim of the ear, then sewn into cuts in both nostril rims
An external graft being taken and sewn in: harvested where the earlobe meets the ear rim (a to d), then stitched into the nostril rims (e). Manafi et al. 2013, Fig. 1. CC BY 3.0.

Key examples

Dr. Jason Roostaeian (US): "Correcting the over-resected alar base." These appear to have healed well, with visibly bigger nostrils.
External

Dr. Jason Roostaeian (US)

"Correcting the over-resected alar base." These appear to have healed well, with visibly bigger nostrils.

View on Instagram

Dr. Amir Sazgar (Tehran), October 2026: One month after rebuilding a nose with six failed surgeries and past skin death. Too early to judge the scars.
External

Dr. Amir Sazgar (Tehran), October 2026

One month after rebuilding a nose with six failed surgeries and past skin death. Too early to judge the scars.

The post · His Instagram

More external examples 1 more
Dr. Shingyochi (Japan), February 2026: A difficult alar revision. You can see the old alarplasty scars at the base of the nostrils.
External

Dr. Shingyochi (Japan), February 2026

A difficult alar revision. You can see the old alarplasty scars at the base of the nostrils.

The post · A 2025 case · His Instagram

Skin tone matters

Ear skin can heal lighter or darker than the skin around it, and scars hold less pigment. On darker skin that's easier to see. Patients have reported external composites healing badly on Black and East Asian skin, and Dr. Toriumi reportedly told a Black patient: "if you were Caucasian, I would consider, but as a black person, I wouldn't recommend it." The studies are mixed, and there's almost no data for the darkest skin types. If you have darker skin, ask to see healed results on people with your skin tone, and lean towards internal.

Bottom line. If you want more size and can live with modest gains, an internal composite graft is the middle ground. External grafts rebuild the most, but the patch can show. Either way, grafts can shrink back over time.

More detail What surgeons said, research, figures, sources

What surgeons told patients

  • Dr. Oguzhan Oguz (Istanbul, August 2026) told a patient he'd only do internal grafts, never external, and advised against external flaps too. Another patient said he suggested external for her, so ask directly.
  • Dr. Sercan Göde said he used to do many composite grafts but now prefers flaps, because grafts must grow a new blood supply and can shrink.
  • Dr. Erkan Soylu turned down one patient because he only does it when the nostrils are very small. Another patient reportedly widened successfully with him.
  • Dr. Ziad Katrib uses internal grafts for pulled-up rims but turned down alarplasty repair.

What the research says

Composite grafts have the most evidence of anything here, though most studies are about injuries, burns and cancer rather than cosmetic alarplasty.

Manafi et al., 2013 (Iran)
  • 56 patients, mostly after too much alar base was cut
  • Small grafts (skin and fat): 47 of 47 took
  • Bigger grafts with cartilage: 5 of 9 excellent, 3 acceptable, 1 failed
  • Not advised over 2 cm. Use flaps instead
Toriumi et al., 2023 (US)
  • 367 grafts in 234 rhinoplasties
  • 93.7% took fully, 6.3% partly or fully failed
Sazgar et al., 2025 (Iran)
  • 45 people with over-cut nostril floor and wing junctions
  • No graft failures, even after past skin death
  • Breathing and appearance scores improved a lot
Asian patients, 2026
  • 15 patients, grafts placed from inside the nostril
  • Mild shrinking and color mismatch at 3 to 6 months
  • Scars "almost indistinguishable" at 1 year; 87% satisfied
Ahuja et al., 2014 (India)
  • 19 patients, all survived, all shrank a little
  • Pigment varied, like a skin graft
  • Keep grafts under 1 cm wide
Agrawal et al., 2025 (India)
  • 11 patients, skin types III to V
  • Over 90% survival, one shrank by about half

A fresh composite graft can look pale, then bluish around day 7, before it pinks up as blood vessels grow in (Jackson and Reisler, 2018). Ask your surgeon what to watch for.

A small rim defect before, during surgery with the graft placed from inside the nostril, and after
Internal: a small rim defect, before, during and after. Front Med 2026, Fig. 3. CC BY 4.0.
Uneven nostrils after rhinoplasty, before and after a small rim graft
External: uneven nostrils after rhinoplasty, fixed with a small rim graft. Manafi et al. 2013, Fig. 3. CC BY 3.0.
Two earlier rhinoplasties, then composite grafts on both nostrils
External: two earlier rhinoplasties, then grafts on both sides. Manafi et al. 2013, Fig. 5. CC BY 3.0.

Sources

  1. Manafi A, et al. Can We Add Auricular Composite Graft to Our Rhinoplasty Armamentarium? World J Plast Surg 2013;2(1):33–40. Full text
  2. Toriumi DM, et al. Auricular Composite Graft Survival in Rhinoplasty. Facial Plast Surg Aesthet Med 2023;25(1):6–15. DOI
  3. Sazgar AA, et al. Single-Stage Alar Nostril Ring Correction Using Auricular Composite Grafts. Aesthet Surg J 2025;45(3):255–263. PubMed
  4. Auricular composite tissue graft for the correction of alar rim defect in Asian patients. Front Med 2026;12:1710063. Full text
  5. Ahuja RB, et al. Securing aesthetic outcomes for composite grafts to alar margin and columellar defects. Indian J Plast Surg 2014;47(3):333–339. Full text
  6. Agrawal KS, et al. Auricular Composite Grafts in Fitzpatrick Type III–V Indian Noses. Aesthetic Plast Surg 2025;49(9):2338–2349. PubMed
  7. Jackson SM, Reisler T. Alar Rim Notching Reconstruction With Auricular Composite Chondrocutaneous Graft. Eplasty 2018;18:ic25. Full text
3

Flaps

Skin that keeps its own blood supply

Move nearby skin into the nostril without ever cutting it off from its blood supply.

A graft (method 2)

is like a cut flower: no roots, so it has to grow new ones or it dies.

A flap (method 3)

is like moving a plant with its roots still on. It keeps its blood supply, so it can't starve.

The trade-off: you need spare skin nearby, you make a new cut where it comes from, and small flaps can shrink unless cartilage holds them in shape.

3a

Alar lobule island flap

Gentlest optionFixes shape, not size

A tiny crescent of spare skin from the outside of the same nostril wing is moved into the notch, usually with a curved piece of ear cartilage to round out the wing. It uses tissue you already have and keeps the scar in the crease. You need a little spare skin on the outer wing for it to work.

Diagram: a crescent of spare skin in the crease is lifted and moved into the notch
The flap: spare skin in the crease is moved into the notch. Ohba et al. 2024, Fig. 2. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.
Teardrop shaped nostrils before, and 18 months after repair with alar lobule flaps and ear cartilage
Teardrop nostrils, 18 months after repair with lobule flaps and ear cartilage. Ohba et al. 2024, Fig. 5. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.

Where: Dr. Norihiro Ohba, Primo Azabujuban Clinic, Tokyo. Dr. Göde and Dr. Tolga Bilece have also offered it to patients.

More detail The study, more figures, practical notes
The study (Ohba et al., 2024)
  • 16 patients, 2016 to 2022, all after cosmetic nostril reduction
  • Main tool: curved ear cartilage, chosen to avoid the color problems of composite grafts
  • Flap added only when there was spare outer wing skin, 2 to 3.5 mm wide at most
Results
  • Every flap survived
  • Nostril shape improved in every case
  • 1 cartilage graft got infected and was removed
  • Typical follow-up about 9 months; retainer worn 6 months
Good to know
  • To widen, the authors release a ligament and use cartilage to push the wings outward
  • Small study, run by the clinic's own surgeons
  • It needs cartilage support, or the groove can flatten
Diagram: a curved piece of ear cartilage placed under the wing skin
The ear cartilage that goes with it. Ohba et al. 2024, Fig. 1.
Diagram: two stitches under the lip that define the crease
Two "cinching" stitches sharpen the crease. Ohba et al. 2024, Fig. 3.
Flat nostril wings and blurred creases before, and 9.5 months after ear cartilage alone
Flat wings fixed with ear cartilage alone, 9.5 months later. Ohba et al. 2024, Fig. 4.

For tight scars and tethering next to the wings, patients have also recommended the Japanese surgeon @tetuichiro, though he wasn't taking overseas patients when asked.

Source

  • Ohba N, Haraoka G, Ohba M, Takahashi N. Treatment of Alar Deformity After Cosmetic Surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open 2024;12(11):e6327. Full text
3b

Lip or cheek island flap

Promising, unprovenThe only option that adds living skin

A small island of new skin from the upper lip or cheek is moved into the nostril while still attached to a stem of blood vessels, so the wing can be pushed back out. Dr. Sercan Göde (Izmir) is the surgeon best known for it. It works well for rebuilding columellas, and he started using it for alarplasty reversal in 2026.

A small oval of lip skin, still connected to its blood vessels, moved into the bottom of the nostril so the wing can sit further out skin island, stillattached to blood vessels wing canmove out
A simplified idea. Real designs vary, and the exact steps for alarplasty repair haven't been published.

Why it's promising

  • The only option that brings new living skin, so in theory the most size
  • Can't die like a graft
  • Nearby skin usually matches better than ear skin

Reasons for caution

  • Very new for alarplasty. Most photos are from the operating table
  • One patient who spoke to 20+ lip flap patients says their bases narrowed again within weeks
  • Skin-only flaps can shrink and flatten the sills
  • Some patients got clear scars on the sill or lip

Key examples

Dr. Sercan Göde, September 2026: "Alar base reversing by local island flaps." Taken on the operating table, so expect it to settle.

Dr. Sercan Göde, September 2026

"Alar base reversing by local island flaps." Taken on the operating table, so expect it to settle.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, October 2026: One year after a complex revision with flaps. The early scars looked rough. One of the few one-year results available.

Dr. Sercan Göde, October 2026

One year after a complex revision with flaps. The early scars looked rough. One of the few one-year results available.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde: "Alar base reduction reversal." A lip island flap case, before and after.

Dr. Sercan Göde

"Alar base reduction reversal." A lip island flap case, before and after.

View on Instagram

More detail How it works, what surgeons said, research, 7 more examples

How it was explained to a patient

The surgeon cuts along the crease, keeps that skin attached, and turns it in to make a new sill, which lets the wing move outward. Cartilage or an internal graft goes underneath for support. Dr. Göde told a patient he'd turn a lip flap toward the wing rim to add width. He also said he hadn't done it on a Black patient yet.

What other surgeons said

  • Dr. Oguz: he's done cheek (nasolabial) flaps for cancer patients and the scars look bad; flaps are too much just for flare.
  • A US surgeon: does flap reconstruction often for cancer patients but would never recommend it for cosmetic patients; his note called flap rotations for alarplasty "very risky."

What doctors have published

No study has tested lip island flaps for cosmetic alarplasty reversal yet, but the building blocks exist:

  • Patel et al., 2022: a flap from the crease moved a pulled-in nostril base outward in 5 patients, with a rim graft for support.
  • Nadjmi et al., 2022: rebuilt a damaged wing with a flap from the opposite nostril base, with matching color.
  • Selçuk et al., 2012: cheek flaps with cartilage support for wing defects. Manafi points to flaps like these for defects over 2 cm.
  • Le Diep Linh et al., 2024: upper lip island flaps to rebuild columellas.
Before: the right nostril base pulled inward and narrowed
Before: right nostril base pulled in. Patel et al. 2022, Fig. 1. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.
Surgical markings for the alar groove flap
The flap design. Patel et al. 2022, Fig. 2.
Nine months after the alar groove flap
Nine months after. Patel et al. 2022, Fig. 3.

More examples

Dr. Sercan Göde, March 2026: A complicated revision with flaps. The video has close-ups of the scars, and opinions differ on how visible they are.

Dr. Sercan Göde, March 2026

A complicated revision with flaps. The video has close-ups of the scars, and opinions differ on how visible they are.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, April 2026: Five months after a complex revision. Patients who reviewed it found the scars noticeable even with a filter.

Dr. Sercan Göde, April 2026

Five months after a complex revision. Patients who reviewed it found the scars noticeable even with a filter.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, January 2026: Tip and columella skin death, two months after reconstruction. Shared to show how his flaps work.

Dr. Sercan Göde, January 2026

Tip and columella skin death, two months after reconstruction. Shared to show how his flaps work.

View on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde: A revision that lengthened the columella and improved retraction. An island flap appears to have been used.

Dr. Sercan Göde

A revision that lengthened the columella and improved retraction. An island flap appears to have been used.

View on Instagram

Photo only viewable on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, March 2025

An alar retraction repair. Some patients noticed teardrop notches afterwards.

View on Instagram

Dr. Oguzhan Oguz, June 2026: "When tissue is lost, reconstruction becomes the only option." Patients have felt his flaps were less refined than Göde's.

Dr. Oguzhan Oguz, June 2026

"When tissue is lost, reconstruction becomes the only option." Patients have felt his flaps were less refined than Göde's.

View on Instagram

Photo only viewable on Instagram

Dr. Sercan Göde, March 2026

An extreme revision on a Black patient after skin death. A very severe case, and the scars are visible.

View on Instagram

Sources

  1. Patel N, et al. Inferiorly Based Alar Groove Flap for Correction of Alar Base Malposition and Nasal Stenosis. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open 2022;10:e4334. Full text
  2. Nadjmi N, et al. A Novel Technique for Nasal Alar Reconstruction. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open 2022;10:e4284. Full text
  3. Selçuk CT, et al. Reconstruction of Full-Thickness Nasal Alar Defects Using Cartilage-Supported Nonfolded Nasolabial Flaps. J Craniofac Surg 2012. Abstract
  4. Le Diep Linh, et al. The Reconstruction of the Nasal Columella Defect Using Domino Flaps. Arch Plast Surg 2024;51(4):367–371. Full text

Bottom line. For notches with spare wing skin, the alar lobule flap with cartilage is the safest option so far. Lip and cheek island flaps are the only real hope for lots of tissue, but there are almost no healed, long-term results yet. Many patients choose to try gentler fixes first and wait for more results.

4

Other options

Usually alongside methods 1 to 3
  • Fix the structure first. Pulled-up or collapsed wings can often be fixed with cartilage grafts before touching skin. One study improved pulled-up rims by about 2.7 mm on average, though heavy scarring limited some results.
  • V-to-Y advancement. A small flap inside the nostril pushed outward, roughly 2 to 3 mm per side. Few surgeons offer it, and at least one botched case with outside scars has been reported.
  • Scar release. Loosening tight scars, sometimes with a Z-shaped cut, can help with smiling, tightness and itching. It won't make nostrils wider.
  • Scar care. Laser, dermabrasion, tretinoin and medical tattooing all helped some patients and not others. Dermabrasion carries pigment risk on darker skin.
  • Wait for swelling to settle. Early on, nostrils can look smaller and stiffer than they'll end up.
More detail Examples, research to watch, sources
Dr. Ziad Katrib: Reinforcing a weak tip with rib cartilage. Structure before skin.

Dr. Ziad Katrib

Reinforcing a weak tip with rib cartilage. Structure before skin.

View on Instagram

Dr. Shingyochi (Japan), March 2026: Fixing the scar and the shape around the nostril.

Dr. Shingyochi (Japan), March 2026

Fixing the scar and the shape around the nostril.

View on Instagram

Research to watch

Verteporfin, a drug being studied for healing with less scarring (Dr. Michael Longaker's lab, Stanford), and lab-grown tissue that survives until it connects to blood vessels (EU research project). Neither is available as a treatment yet.

Sources

  1. Marianetti TM, et al. Correction of alar rim retraction by lateral crural extension graft. Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital 2020;40(3):211–216. Full text
  2. Randall NR, Peraza LR, Hamilton GS. Correction and prevention of tip asymmetries, bossae, and alar retraction. Plast Aesthet Res 2024;11:18. Full text

Before you book

Questions to ask any surgeon

  1. Is my problem rotation, a pulled-up rim, weak cartilage, or missing skin? Each has a different fix.
  2. Can I see results a year or more after surgery, not on the operating table? Grafts and flaps have been reported to shrink back within weeks.
  3. Have you done this on someone with my skin tone? Can I talk to them?
  4. Will the graft or flap go inside or outside? Where will every scar be?
  5. What will hold the new shape? Ask whether cartilage support is part of the plan.
  6. Which stitches will you use outside, and when do they come out? Facial stitches usually come out around day 7.
  7. What's your plan for scar care afterwards?
  8. Exactly how many millimeters will you add or remove, and will it be in my report?
  9. If I don't like it, can it be undone?
  10. Will you do anything I haven't agreed to in writing? Some patients have woken up with an alarplasty they never asked for.

Everything in one place

Sources and links

All studies and examples from this page. Personal accounts and anything not about repair are left out.

Studies 15
  1. Ohba N, et al. Treatment of Alar Deformity After Cosmetic Surgery. PRS Global Open 2024. Full text
  2. Manafi A, et al. Can We Add Auricular Composite Graft to Our Rhinoplasty Armamentarium? World J Plast Surg 2013. Full text
  3. Toriumi DM, et al. Auricular Composite Graft Survival in Rhinoplasty. Facial Plast Surg Aesthet Med 2023. DOI
  4. Sazgar AA, et al. Single-Stage Alar Nostril Ring Correction Using Auricular Composite Grafts. Aesthet Surg J 2025. PubMed
  5. Auricular composite tissue graft for alar rim defect in Asian patients. Front Med 2026. Full text
  6. Ahuja RB, et al. Composite grafts to alar margin and columellar defects. Indian J Plast Surg 2014. Full text
  7. Agrawal KS, et al. Auricular Composite Grafts in Fitzpatrick Type III–V Indian Noses. Aesthetic Plast Surg 2025. PubMed
  8. Jackson SM, Reisler T. Alar Rim Notching Reconstruction With Auricular Composite Graft. Eplasty 2018. Full text
  9. Patel N, et al. Inferiorly Based Alar Groove Flap for Alar Base Malposition. PRS Global Open 2022. Full text
  10. Nadjmi N, et al. A Novel Technique for Nasal Alar Reconstruction. PRS Global Open 2022. Full text
  11. Selçuk CT, et al. Full-Thickness Alar Defects With Cartilage-Supported Nasolabial Flaps. J Craniofac Surg 2012. Abstract
  12. Le Diep Linh, et al. Reconstruction of the Nasal Columella Using Domino Flaps. Arch Plast Surg 2024. Full text
  13. Marianetti TM, et al. Correction of Alar Rim Retraction by Lateral Crural Extension Graft. 2020. Full text
  14. Rohrich RJ, Afrooz PN. Revisiting the Alar-Columellar Relationship. Plast Reconstr Surg 2019. PubMed
  15. Randall NR, et al. Correction and prevention of tip asymmetries, bossae, and alar retraction. Plast Aesthet Res 2024. Full text
Instagram examples by method 26 posts

1. Derotation

  • Dr. Sam Most, June 2023

    A long-term revision result. The nostrils look fuller after derotation. This patient never had an alarplasty. Video, so play it on Instagram.

  • Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2025

    Seven months after a revision to bring down an upturned tip.

  • Dr. Ari Hyman, August 2023

    Three months after a revision to correct uneven nostrils. Shared as an example of strong derotation.

2a. Internal composite grafts

  • Dr. Oguzhan Oguz Internal (April 2026 video)

    Rebuilding a lost nostril from the inside: before, at 1 month and at 7 months. It appears to have healed well. He posted the same case again in April 2026 as a video.

  • Dr. Kidakorn Kiranantawat (Thailand), 2024 Internal

    Severe nostril narrowing after cosmetic surgery, fixed with a composite graft from the ear. Shown 1 year and 10 months later.

  • Dr. Sercan Göde Internal

    "Larger and better nostrils are possible." Rib cartilage plus composite grafts, on darker skin.

  • Dr. Ahmet Halit Aydın, May 2024 Internal

    A complicated ethnic revision with a composite graft on one side. One of very few published examples on a Black patient.

  • Dr. Shahriar Nazari (Iran) Internal

    From his Instagram stories, tagged "alar expansion". His captions read "nasal reconstruction and enlarging the nasal ala".

  • Dr. Sercan Göde, 2024 Internal

    An alar retraction repair. One patient recalls this case differently, as outside grafts that scarred, so ask him directly.

2b. External composite grafts

3b. Lip and cheek island flaps

4. Other

Surgeons and clinics mentioned As reported by patients
Word list What the doctor words mean
Ala (alae)
The nostril wing.
Alar lobule
The soft, rounded part of the wing near the bottom.
Alar crease
The groove where the wing meets your cheek.
Sill
The little floor at the bottom of each nostril.
Columella
The strip of skin between the nostrils.
Alarplasty
Surgery that cuts skin from the nostrils to make them smaller. Also called alar base reduction.
Weir excision
An alarplasty that cuts both the sill and a wedge from the wing.
Flare
How much the wings curve outward.
Notching, teardrop deformity
A dent in the nostril edge, or a nostril pulled into a teardrop shape.
Retraction
When the nostril rim is pulled up too high.
Nostril show
How much of the nostril openings you can see.
Rotation, derotation
Turning the nose tip up, or back down.
SEG
Septal extension graft. A strong cartilage piece that sets where the tip points.
Cartilage graft
Cartilage only. Adds support and shape, not skin.
Composite graft
Skin plus cartilage (or fat), moved as one piece. Adds skin.
Flap
Tissue moved while staying attached to its blood supply.
Island flap
A flap attached only by a small stem of blood vessels, so it can move further.
Table photo
A photo taken on the operating table. Results look better than they'll end up.
Fitzpatrick type
A scale from I (very fair) to VI (deeply pigmented). Matters for scars and pigment.